We may gain revenue from the product available on this page and take part in affiliate programs . acquire More ›
MIG vs. TIG welding is a debate that has been expire on for decades . Both are types of arc welding unremarkably used by amateurs and professional alike . Both offer versatility and relatively low-cost equipment . So which is best ?
Even though they sound like — and the welding machines look likewise at first coup d’oeil — they are far from the same . In truth , the question of which type of welding is good depends upon which is the most appropriate for the job at script .
Photo: istockphoto.com
sympathize the difference of opinion between MIG and TIG welding is key to the success of any project , and that ’s what novice welders in particular can learn from this article .
What is MIG welding?
MIG stands for “ metal inert gas , ” and it ’s also have it off as gas metallic element electric discharge welding ( GMAW ) . MIG welding simple machine get a herculean electrical electric current that runs through a handheld common mullein . The woolly mullein supply the welding gas and mechanically give the MIG welding conducting wire . This conducting wire create an electrical arc that mellow the metallic element being join and provides makeweight stuff to strengthen the joint . A ground clamp is attached to the workpiece to protect the welder from shocks .
Welding Gas
MIG welding gases are soggy , so they have no impingement on the chemic reaction within a dyer’s mignonette . The most common is a mix of argon and carbon copy dioxide . The aim of MIG welding gas ( also call shield gas ) is to protect the molten metal ( the weld consortium ) from impurities present in the air travel . Hydrogen , nitrogen , and oxygen in the air travel around us can make unreasonable spattering ( liquefied metal thrown out of the weld ) and porosity ( air bubble within a dyer’s mignonette ) , the latter of which creates weaknesses in the finished line .
Not all MIG welders involve a freestanding natural gas supply . With gasless MIG ( or flux density - Congress of Racial Equality welding ) , the welding wire is coated with chemical substance that mold their own shield as the wire thawing .
Weld Speed
Speed is an of import factor when it come to the doubt of TIG vs. MIG welding , and the latter is by far the debauched of the two . A MIG welding automobile feeds welding wire through the torch automatically , at a upper set by the user . Beginners can slow up the wire to suit their skill level , while professional can rush along it up to maximize productiveness .
One drawback of MIG welding is that it does n’t create such a neat weld , so superfluous prison term may be postulate to clean things up for painting or electroplating .
Weld Strength
Any properly form weld is exceedingly inviolable . As an previous proverb say , the weld is in reality stronger than the original metal . This is straight of any beneficial MIG weld , but care is required . Although MIG welding produces a relatively large and easy - to - manage pocket billiards of liquified metal , trying to weld too promptly can produce odd penetration that guide to weaknesses .
Protection offered by the shield throttle is a lively constituent . Any steer can disrupt this bubble and countenance in impurities , so received MIG welding can not be performed outdoors . One solution for this is agasless MIG welder , although these ca n’t be used for MIG welding aluminum .
Our Recommendation : Forney Easy Weld 140 FC - i Flux - Core Wire Welder at Amazon for $ 250.24.This democratic , mellow - quality MIG welder is light , easy to apply , and offers the performance necessary for a spacious range of home and professional welding tasks .
Photo: istockphoto.com
What is TIG welding?
TIG stands for “ tungsten torpid gas , ” and it ’s also get laid as natural gas tungsten arc welding ( GTAW ) . With TIG welding , the electrode deliver the electric charge is made of tungsten , and ( unlike MIG conducting wire ) it is non - consumable . An extra filler rod must be used as a result , which is held in the welder ’s other hand . coordinate the two demands greater concentration than when work with MIG .
As with MIG welding , TIG welding requires gas to screen the Reseda luteola from impureness . It also helps prevent the fixed TIG electrode from overheating . TIG welding gas is usually compose of Ar or a mix of argon and He ( another sluggish accelerator pedal ) . Argon and hydrogen are used when TIG weld stainless steel .
Argon and argon / He shields are sound than the argon / C dioxide mix ordinarily used with MIG welding , so it ’s possible to TIG weld outdoors in tranquil conditions . However , it can still be a challenge . One widely available answer is a combo motorcar design for outdoor use that includes stick welding , another choice among thedifferent case of welding .
Photo: istockphoto.com
TIG welding is a dense process than MIG welding . This is partly due to welders ’ take to organise the natural action of both hired hand . There ’s also the forcible restriction of manually fertilize the makeweight rods into the Reseda luteola pool one at a time . For these reason , it is n’t possible to TIG weld as quickly as with MIG ’s automated conducting wire .
The upside of TIG welding is greater control . The Reseda luteola consortium is relatively little , piss TIG a well option when the appearance of a weld is significant . This cognitive process also makes it possible to weld thinner material than can be done with MIG .
Because TIG welding produces smaller and neater dyer’s mignonette than MIG , it ’s ideal for welding thinner materials . Also , the intensity of the Theodore Dwight Weld penetrates textile more deep , so TIG weld strength is greater .
Photo: istockphoto.com
This is particularly true when TIG welding lightweight aluminum , as well as when work with smaller property . MIG can plainly be too powerful and can incinerate right through the material , whereas TIG provides the necessary preciseness .
Our Recommendation : AHP AlphaTIG 203XI at Amazon for $ 750.This versatile machine can raise preciseness Weld in sword , stainless steel , and aluminum , and has the added bonus of stick welding capableness .
MIG welding is best for joining thick or large materials, while TIG welding is better for thin or small pieces.
Both MIG and TIG can develop a motley of unlike types of welds in steel , unsullied steel , and aluminum . Generally verbalise , however , the speed and power of MIG welding is better suit to more substantial projects . MIG is a heavy choice for hobby welder concerned in motorcar repair , building brand furniture , or creating steel carving for the garden .
While MIG weld untarnished steel and aluminium is possible , TIG welding is generally reckon the better choice with these materials . untarnished steel and Al are more susceptible to heat variation and can be foxy to weld well . When lean descent is used , TIG offer a higher degree of control and results in smaller , neater welds . Once the proficiency is mastered , TIG welders can achieve a fine finish requiring niggling or no clean - up work before finishing .
Because TIG welding is more technically demanding, MIG is easier to learn for beginners.
MIG welding is invariably considered the best eccentric of welding for founder . The technique is easy to memorise and more forgiving . Most welder start out exploit with average steel ( aka balmy steel ) , which the MIG welding process is ideal for . High qualityMIG welding equipment suited for beginnersis usually less expensive than TIG welding equipment .
TIG welding requires both hands , and while the king ascendency may be located on the master unit , many machines use a foot pedal point . This , of form , involves increase coordination . The reinforcement for learning TIG welding is the power to weld a wider stove of materials and give rise more precise , high quality piece of work . However , solitaire is required and the TIG process can not be rushed . submit awelding courseis always a unspoilt idea for novice welders and highly recommended for those who need to learn how to TIG weld .
MIG welds are generally weaker and less aesthetically pleasing than TIG welds.
The proportional strengths and optical appeal of welds are often discussed in MIG vs. TIG welding discourse . The general consensus is that MIG welds are weaker and TIG Reseda luteola are better - looking , but this can be somewhat misleading .
MIG welding is not unaccented ; a well - mould MIG Theodore Dwight Weld has tremendous strength and durability . It ’s important to use the right process for any especial project , however . TIG welding can be strong when joining humble items and welding aluminum , but it ’s rarely used for heavy - tariff structures . MIG welding is more appropriate and provide all of the needed persuasiveness for such line of work .
While it is true that TIG welds are usually more esthetically pleasing , it should be kept in mind that items being TIG weld are often lightweight , so these weld are of course minor . MIG dyer’s rocket are frequently larger and more raised , but there ’s no inherent intellect they ca n’t be smooth and neat .
Photo: istockphoto.com
MIG welding costs less than TIG overall.
A numeral of constituent have an impingement on the overall cost of MIG vs. TIG welding , but MIG usually work out cheaper from both a DIY and commercial point of prospect .
While low price TIG welding machine are useable and furnish an affordable introduction to the process , high-pitched timbre machines for those who designate to TIG weld on a regular basis are generally around twice the monetary value of an equivalent MIG welder . MIG welding wire is a little brassy than TIG welding rods , though it is n’t usually a significant factor .
In commercial environs , speed of working can be a major divisor . Not only is TIG slower , but component part to be weld need more careful preparation . As a result , job costs rise . It may also be the eccentric that a skilled TIG welder receives higher remuneration than a MIG - only welder .
When To Use MIG vs. TIG Welding
There is n’t really an overall winner in the MIG vs. TIG argument . Although these eccentric of welding are interchangeable to some extent , each has its strengths and weaknesses . Understanding these pros and cons is the key to knowing which welding cognitive operation will produce the best results . Although there are periodic exception , the follow is a useful overview :
At this stage , it is worth cite welding safety and personal protective equipment ( PPE ) . A welding helmet , weld jacket or apron , and properwelding glovesare all vital for obviate burns and a painful type of eye injury known as “ welder ’s flash ” or “ arc center . ” Fortunately , the same high - timber welding PPE can be used for all shape of welding .
Final Thoughts
While both are excellent ways of joining metal , the MIG vs. TIG welding debate will likely continue . They both have their pros and cons , meaning neither one is “ good ” than the other overall .
From a founder ’s point of view , MIG welding is undoubtedly easier to learn than TIG . It ’s more affordable , can fulfill most DIY welding tasks , and delivers strong , long-lasting welds with a little drill .
A skilled welding professional will always produce a neater weld with TIG welding than they can with MIG , but that level of preciseness often is n’t necessary in your garage or yard . Most people who learn TIG welding will have started with MIG , anyway , moving on to TIG when a job demands it .
The price listed here are accurate as of publication on 12/20/22 .
This Is the Year for a Kitchen Renovation
Whether you ’re sell or staying , everyone can get something out of a kitchen update . Learn why we debate this renovation the Most Valuable Project of 2025 and how to stay on budget .
