We may earn tax income from the products available on this Sir Frederick Handley Page and take part in affiliate programs . get word More ›
When it comes down to vermiculite vs. perlite , the name may prejudice you in favour of the second contender . Perlite , after all , derives from the French for “ pearl ” while vermiculite derives from Latin for the considerably less appealing “ engender worm . ”
However , perlite does n’t really resemble pearl any more than vermiculite resembles louse , and both amendments can improve the porosity and piss retentivity of land . While neither is perfect , they each have advantage as well as disadvantage and have prove to be gems to gardeners everywhere .
Photo: Tom Fenenga for Bob VIla
What is vermiculite?
Vermiculite is a flaky clay mineral , in more ways than one . When heated to about 570 grade Fahrenheit , it spread up into lightweight , tan insect - like strands , thus the “ cover worm ” its name implies . The size of the flakes pee-pee unlike grades of vermiculite from micro to coarse . Those spongy particle can oxygenise soil and help it keep back moisture .
Vermiculite drop off some popularity when the product from a mine in Montana , which had been in operation since 1919 , was encounter — after a 1999 EPA investigating — to be “ contaminated with a toxic shape of naturally occurring asbestos . ” However , that mine had closed in 1990 .
In 2000 , the EPA reported that it had tested vermiculite products from all over the nation and concluded that “ only 15 percent of these products bear enough asbestos to give up EPA to quantify the percentage of asbestos reliably . Further analysis of the likelihood of the asbestos becoming airborne , during routine function of these products , indicated that this likely vulnerability poses a minimal wellness risk to consumers . ” The EPA did close , however , that vermiculite might be serious to workers who come into contact with it frequently .
Photo: Tom Fenenga for Bob Vila
What is perlite?
What is perlite made of ? You might say that it is “ popped ” natural glass . That glass , which in its natural nation can be any of a smorgasbord of colours , is created by the speedy cooling of lava . When it is crushed and then stir up to 1,800 to 3,200 degrees Fahrenheit , the steam pin down inside it causes the glass to puff out into bloodless part four to twenty time their original size of it .
The resulting product is idle and poriferous . That makes it ideal for creating drain channels in potting ground without adding excessive exercising weight to that soil as backbone sometimes does . Perlite , too , comes in all right to coarse grades .
The disadvantage of perlite include its fluorine message , which could be detrimental to plants sensitive to that chemical — this includes lily , prayer plant life , andspider plant . Although psychometric test have regain that the fluorine in perlite leaching out pretty quickly , it probably would be best to avert using it in the grime of fluorine - sensitive species .
Photo: Tom Fenenga for Bob Vila
The biggest difference between vermiculite and perlite is moisture retention.
When making the perlite vs. vermiculite decision , keep in nous that difference between the two admit the fact that vermiculite contain nutrients such as atomic number 19 , magnesium , and calcium , which perlite does n’t have . Also , the orotund - ish perlite sometimes be adrift to the top of soil , create it less likely than the flatter vermiculite to persist equally spread throughout the pot . However , vermiculite compact more easily , which can reduce its power to aerate . So it reportedly does n’t hold up quite as well as perlite does .
The main difference between the two , however , is that , while perlite for plants can suck up four fourth dimension its system of weights in piss , vermiculite sponges up to sixteen times its weight unit in water . So , vermiculite is more in force at assemblage and redistributingmoisturethan perlite is . Whether or not that is an advantage depends on the type of plants you are growing .
One affair the amendment have in common is that they engender a raft of detritus . Therefore , if you determine tomix your own potting soil , you will want to wear a dust masquerade party or gasmask while doing so .
Photo: Tom Fenenga for Bob Vila
When to amend soil with vermiculite:
What is vermiculite used for ? Due to its water - hold ability , vermiculite is typically used forseed - start , whether on its own or mixed with peat moss . Damp vermiculite also can be used to salt away seeds that will lose viability if allow to dry out . Vermiculite often is summate to the soil of moisture - loving potted works such asferns , primroses , and calla lilies , which , too , can turn a loss their lives if allowed to dry out .
Gardeners who rest in already excessively damp climate probably should avoid comprise vermiculite into the soil of out-of-door pots , since it might retain too much weewee and have their plants to rot . But nurseryman in drought - prone surface area could find vermiculite highly beneficial , since soil containing it should hold moisture longer than that containing perlite . Those who oftenforget to watertheir indoor industrial plant believably should prefer for vermiculite over perlite , too .
When to amend soil with perlite:
What is perlite used for ? Its damp “ pearl , ” on their own , often are used toroot cutting , because perlite is less likely to cause rot than vermiculite is . Perlite also is a popular addition to pot commixture for plants that necessitate fantabulous drainage and not too much moisture — such ascactiandsucculents — since soil with perlite included prohibitionist out more quickly than that contain vermiculite . gardener in sozzled climate may want to add perlite to the territory in their outside pots to help those container enfeeble more freely . And those who tend to overwater their indoor plants can find it beneficial for preventing rot there , too .
Although you conceivably could add either perlite or vermiculite to elicit beds or garden as well , you probably will find it more virtual and scotch touse compostinstead to improve filth aeration and water retention in a big - plate growing area . That specially applies to non - raised bed since perlite can be pulverized by foot dealings , while vermiculite is likely to be compressed by it .
Our Best Advice for Beginner Gardeners
We ’ll help you place up your first garden — whether that ’s a few tummy on your patio , a raised bed , or an in - ground patch out back — and choose the correct plants for your dirt and neighborhood .
