Best Overall
Green Gobbler 20% Vinegar Weed Killer
Best Bang for the Buck
Calyptus 50% Pure Concentrated Vinegar
Best for Lawn Weeds
Sunday Weed Warrior Herbicide
We may gain gross from the products uncommitted on this page and participate in affiliate programs . pick up More ›
Weed sea wolf can inhibit invasive sess specie and keep them from infest the lawn , garden , and landscape . But banishing weeds need n’t harm the environs . Generations of chemical research worker have grow numerous muscular herbicides for home enjoyment that are highly efficient , relatively cheap , and soft to apply . We of late put five of these low - toxicity weed killer to the test to assess their efficaciousness .
After testing each product for more than two weeks , our top pick isGreen Gobbler 20 % Vinegar Weed Killer . We sprayed it onto a large expanse of weeds and saw die - off within hours . We also liked that it came ready to use in a commodious spray bottle .
Other tested products also performed well . Read on for a list of the beneficial sess killer on the grocery store and primal shopping tips to help you find the good one for yourlawn careneeds .
Weed Killers Comparison Chart
Our Top Picks
We tested a variety of highly effective weed killers with low environmental perniciousness that are safe for regular thou and garden maintenance . Not all pot killer are the same . For that ground , our card includes options to barricade one-year pesky weeds from stock and to knock out bad perennial grasses throughout the landscape painting . Here ’s how our choices perform in our mental test , and why we guess they are some of the proficient weed killer around .
Green Gobbler makes catch - and - go green goddess control gentle with no mixture need . This quart - size trigger - spray bottleful is ready to utilize with 20 percentage vinegar and pee solution . Just twist the on / spray switch and target grassy and broadleaf weeds .
The Green Gobbler ’s compact package and ready - to - spray bottleful were commodious , but to nullify damage from overspray , we had to hold the induction atomizer within about 12 inches of direct grass , which increased stooping and bending compared to tank nebulizer with farseeing spray wands . The fine mist of this weed and grass killer coated weed leafage well but with more spray mist drift than our coarse atomizer verge emit . We also had to exit the orbit at separation due to the overwhelming smell .
What our examiner says:“I tested Green Gobbler acetum grass and weed orca at the sharpness of landscape bed where creeping grasses had begun to entrench and among veg plant within raised garden beds , and it work within hour . ” – Mark Wolfe , Product Reviews examiner and writer
Get the Green Gobbler weed and grass slayer atAmazon(2 - pack),The Home Depot , orGreen Gobbler .
To apply this toll - efficient biodegradable product to defoliate and kill weeds quickly , dilute one part of this pure , extremely concentrated vinegar with up to eight parts water supply and apply with a nebuliser . The high-pitched acid subject erodes folio cadre and dries out leafage within 2 to 24 hour . This locoweed killer is best used in mulched bed and other found areas but is not ideal for patios , sidewalk , or drive . Repeated contact with concrete , natural stone , mortar , and some other hardscape surfaces may induce etching .
We were extremely careful when stretch this saturated Calyptus acetum and recommend that all user follow suit , wreak outdoors for good ventilating system and wear goggles and galosh gloves to protect against middle and tegument irritation . We also double - agree to ensure all of the nebulizer ’s home component part were made of plastic , since this dose could damage rubber and metal . We apply the weed killer on herbaceous weeds in garden nerve pathway and vacant garden beds . All of the smallest weed kick the bucket within a few minute . institute , unwanted Bermuda supergrass Caranx crysos browned out in 5 to 6 hours , but where the pasture was the deep , only the exterior constituent turn brown .
This weed killer smell out so intensely of vinegar that we had to take the air off from the surface area during discourse several times . The strong odor remained in the yard for about 24 hour . Calyptus killed more mourning band for less money than the other skunk slayer we examine .
Get the Calyptus weed killer atAmazon .
Photo: Debbie Wolfe for Bob Vila
This congius - size Sunday Weed Warrior is premixed and comes with its own battery - power spray pump / wand . Its ammoniated soap formula adheres well to flick surfaces and begins killing weeds and grass on inter-group communication . As a nonselective smoke orca , it ’s intended for direct place discussion only — overspray will damage or kill lawn Gunter Wilhelm Grass . To use , give the jugful a good handshaking , deploy the sprayer adapter into the capital , and begin spray .
We used Sunday Weed Warrior dope killer spray on crabgrass , clover , plantain , and wild violet , and it started working within two hours . This locoweed killer for lawns also penetrate and killed Bermuda grass shoot more thoroughly than the acetum products : Near total dieback occurred after one applications programme , whereas acetum killed off only the surface leave and go away green blades beneath .
The stamp battery - operate on sprayer was easy to practice and worked well , educe almost every drop of liquid from the jug . Plus , aconcentrated refill containeris available to order directly from the maker . Sunday Weed Warrior is an excellent fast - vote out locoweed killer for lawns , as long as users take precautions to protect against overspray .
What our tester says:“I tested Sunday Weed Warrior on crabgrass , trefoil , Musa paradisiaca , and angry reddish blue in several lawn areas as well as on crack mourning band on the driveway and pavement . It worked faster than vinegar - base products , with noticeable dieback in less than 2 hours and thorough brownout in about 18 hours . ” – Mark Wolfe , mathematical product Reviews examiner and author
Get the Sunday Weed Warrior weed sea wolf atAmazon(32 - ounce touch handling , 2 - pack),Walmart(1 gallon),Target(1 congius ) , orSunday(32 - Panthera uncia spot treatment , 2 - pack ) .
Best for Dandelions
Sunday Dandelion Doom Herbicide
Selective herbicide that are safe for lawn and infer from born constituent are rarefied , but Sunday Dandelion Doom lawn weed killer spray match the bill . The active fixings , iron HEDTA , is spoiled news for broadleaf weeds but safe to expend on grass . This 1 - congius parcel is ready to spray and comes with its own battery - powered nebulizer attachment . Shake well , plug in the spray adapter , and spot spray dandelions , clover , thistle , and other weeds without damage the lawn .
We tested Dandelion Doom in an out - of - the - way lawn area that was somewhat infested with clover , blowball , wild violet , crabgrass , and a few other weeds . After marking a small test plot of land , we spray the grass individually , without being specially deliberate about overspray . After 24 hours , we point out discoloration of the dandelion , clover , and violets . After the third day , most of the broadleaf green goddess appeared dead .
Unlike other smoke sess control spraying that cause weeds to dry out and turn brown , this merchandise made the leaves work fatal . The lawn grass and crabgrass appeared unaffected . Because of our curiosity about atomic number 26 staining , we also spray a few weeds in crack on the concrete driveway . The weed buy the farm there in about 2 days , but the concrete did not stain . Sunday Dandelion Doom is an first-class pick to keep broadleaf mourning band out of lawn area .
Photo: Amazon
Get the Sunday Dandelion Doom weed orca atWalmart(1 - Imperial gallon bottle , 2 - gang ) orSunday(32 - snow leopard spot treatment , 2 - pack ) .
Best for Gravel Areas
Bonide Captain Jack’s Deadweed Brew Concentrate
The combat-ready ingredient capric pane , a concentrated fat that comes from coconut and palm kernel crude , kills broadleaf and grassy weeds by drying out the foliage . It makes Captain Jack ’s Deadweed Brew an efficacious desiccant for gravel areas prone to weeds . The concentrate comes in a quart - size software with a dedicated mensuration cup . Mix it with body of water to make up to 8 gal of spray - on inter-group communication gage killer .
We prove Deadweed Brew on a lower-ranking crushed rock driveway that was fundamentally two graveled tire tracks with a ridgeline of green weeds down the middle . Because of the magniloquent , dim weed screen , we prepared the situation by first pout it down with a string trimming capacitor and removing the clip . Then we waited 3 day for some foliage regrowth to occur before broadcasting the spraying over the entire sens zone with a backpack sprayer , having localize the nozzle on a coarse spray radiation pattern .
Within 4 time of day after the midmorning spray software , the weed geographical zone had turn a pale greenish brown . By the next morning , all the weeds were completely brown . We appreciated that this dressed ore was smell - liberal , even at full strength . Captain Jack ’s preferred - safe weed sea wolf eradicates lot of weeds over with child area without noxious odors .
Photo: Amazon
Get the Bonide weed killer atAmazon , Lowe’s(1 gallon , quick to use),Walmart , orBonide .
Or, DIY Your Own Weed Killer
Buying the best rude weed orca on the marketplace is a reliable option for killing weeds . But , for those of us who prefer the DIY plan of attack , there is an at - dwelling house remedy that kills weeds and can be made with the canonical necessity found in most kitchen .
Bob Vila ’s favorite recipe involves blend the following component in a large arena :
After these ingredient are blend , the mixture should be poured into a spray feeding bottle or sprayer and then applied to the undesirable plants . For best result , this mixture should be applied on a sunny day so the heat dries out and shrivels the weeds . The combination of the sess grampus and the Lord’s Day will set on the root systems of the weeds and speed up the killing process .
Photo: Lowe’s
This assortment will produce a full gallon of natural green goddess Orcinus orca that can be applied to large or modest patches of smoke . The remnants can be label and stored in the service department or with other cleanup supplies . It should be keep open aside from children and pets between gage mastery software .
Jump to Our Top Picks
How We Tested the Best Weed Killers
retailer offer a all-embracing selection of chemical , natural , and constitutive weed killers , but many weedkiller are linked to suchunintended consequencesas perniciousness to nontargeted plants and animals , body of water contamination , and human health danger .
vulgar grass killer pick , likeSpectracide Weed & Grass Killer Concentrate , Southern Ag Amine 2,4 - 500 Weed Killer , andOrtho Nutsedge Killer for Lawns , use harsh chemical substance . Because these ingredient can harm desirable works , world , and domestic pets , we chose to recommend products for lawn skunk control that check rude vinegar , corn gluten repast , capric acid and caprylic pane , and iron HEDTA , making them safe for house with children and pets running around .
After research 43 democratic lawn and garden herbicide , we take and tested five low - toxicity weed killers . We were confident that they would prove to be extremely effective when used as directed and safe for veritable use based on their human and environmental impacts .
Photo: Lowe’s
We time the program program of weed cause of death to stave off inclement weather and try out each on a minimum of 100 solid feet , harmonise to the instructions on the label . All liquid products were applied using a backpack sprayer , or the applicator include with the product when provided , with the spray beak adjusted to a harsh pattern to avoid sprayer trend . We inspected software area 2 , 4 , 8 , 18 , and 24 hours after spraying and noted the design of dieback . Then we waited 7 days and begin inspecting day by day for sign of regrowth .
With each of the weed slayer we prove , dieback occurred within 3 mean solar day or less of the initial handling , with no signs of regrowth for 2 weeks or more . When regrowth of recurrent or woody - stemmed weeds did take place , it was importantly diminished compared to the pretreatment coming into court . Secondary applications of the same products on regrowth in each area led to similar dieback blueprint along with even slower , less vigorous regrowth .
What to Consider When Choosing the Best Weed Killer
Weed killers are not interchangeable . Some herbicides kill on contact , while others work systemically . Some selectively kill specific types of weed , and others stamp out a blanket spectrum of botany . Be certain to take the types of weeds that involve to be controlled , where they are growing , their ontogeny degree , and the weather conditions .
Even a well - reviewed weed killer will deliver poor results if it is applied incorrectly or if the product is not contrive to work out a specific pot problem . For instance , a vegetation killer designed to annihilate and prevent driveway weeds would devastate a lawn , while a lawn weed orca would be ineffectual against some of the tough weeds that grow in concrete cracks . To maximize product performance and minimize the endangerment of weed killer failure , factor in weed - killer whale case , weed it should attack , and other properties when select the right commercial sens killer .
Type
If you want to avoid frustratinggardening mistakes , choosing the right weed killer for the job is crucial . Here are some of the most vulgar type of weedkiller .
Ingredients
Organic weed killersuse ingredients like vinegar , which burns weed foliage with its acidulent pH , and herbicidal Georgia home boy that dry out out the weeds . Killing weeds naturallyis an fantabulous selection for situations where a non - toxic weed killer formula is crucial , such as in a vegetable garden , baby ’s resort area , or dog common . The ingredient in innate and constitutive weedkiller are biodegradable , so they pose the least threat to humans and beast and do not foul waterways .
A instinctive herbicide for weeds is nonselective and most effective against unseasoned , tender mourning band seedling , but it may kill any other plant in close proximity . Here are some other ingredients that may be let in in organic weed killers .
Form
Weed killers typically come in either a liquidity atomiser or granular formulation .
Emergence
Emergence refer to the degree of weed growth at which weed killer is applied . Users have the alternative of either pre - emergent weed killers or post - emergent weed sea wolf depending upon preference :
Weed Type
There are three type of weeds : yearly , repeated , and biyearly . yearly weeds be for a individual season and then drop dead with the comer of winter , spread their seeds to take root word and grow the next twelvemonth . Pre - emergent herbicide , which stop the seed from germinating , are often the best solution for this character of weed .
recurrent weeds have tooth root organisation that stash away food during cold time of year , which they employ to uprise in the spring . Biennial grass have a 2 - year growing time of year ; the first year they grow and the 2d yr they produce seeds before dying . Both perennial and biennial weeds are easy to bolt down in the belated summer or fall , just before they go into their inactive leg . Liquid weed - killer sprays are the most effective option for perennial and biennial weeds .
Longevity
Some pot killers degrade in soil within a few days to week . While they need more frequent reapplication to keep green goddess at bay laurel , they allow user to replant the area preferably without risking impairment to new industrial plant . This gain them a better option for use in flower or vegetable garden that are soon to be planted as well as in seat where a weed preventer is less good , like gaps between paver Lucy Stone in the yard .
Longer - lasting weed killers stay in the stain and keep fresh weeds from farm in the practical program arena for month or even a year after program . They ’re a good choice for lawns or garden requiring long-lived weed mastery , but they can also inhibit the germination of new plants in the area . Users should avoid applying these pot cause of death to areas where they plan to add new harvest in the near future .
FAQs
If you ’re wondering if weed slayer is dependable to use around positron emission tomography and people or what type is best for killing mourning band in private road cracks , interpret on for answers to these and other normally ask questions about these herbicides .
Though it depends on the character of weeds , the best locoweed killer for driveways will eliminate existing plant and preclude new maturation from expanding driveway sally . For this , the use of both a pre - emerging and post - emergent weed killer would be helpful .
Yes , some weed sea wolf can be toxic to people and animal . Recent studies , however , show that even toxic Mary Jane killers can be safe around people and favorite if the focussing are followed closely and the ware is used sparingly .
Photo: Amazon
Natural gage killers are effective at killing immature , cranky weeds outright . Since perennial mourning band have launch stem systems , they will in all probability grow back after being defoliated with a natural weed killer . One or more keep an eye on - up treatments on regrowth may be necessary to kill the tough weeds .
Pulling weedsout of the background from the base is the undecomposed bet for for good kill them .
Yes , vinegar can be used as a grass killer whale . Some commercial-grade weed killers apply hard acetum as a natural alternative to celluloid chemical .
Our Best Advice for Beginner Gardeners
We ’ll help you set up your first garden — whether that ’s a few pots on your terrace , a stir bottom , or an in - background secret plan out back — and choose the right plants for your soil and region .
